Decisions Restricted For Cleveland Catholics Who Object to J&J Vaccine | Well being


Catholic leaders this week expressed moral concerns about the Johnson & Johnson COVID-19 vaccine as it was made in part using fetal cell lines from an abortion. They say Catholics should go for Pfizer or Moderna vaccines first, which also used a fetal cell line in research but not in production.

But in northeast Ohio and most other parts of the world there is little option, said Father Joseph Koopman of the Catholic Diocese of Cleveland.

“Given the choice, encourage believers like me to consider taking over the Pfizer, Moderna, through Johnson & Johnson. But it looks like that choice doesn’t exist, ”he said.

Dr. Robyn Strosaker, chief operating officer of the university hospitals, said UH will try to work with patients’ preferences, but they have no control over what type of vaccines they get from the state.

“We let all of our patients know what type of vaccine they will be receiving at the time of planning,” she said. “If the patient didn’t want the Johnson & Johnson vaccine when we had another option, we’d certainly like to consider that if we could.”

She said the hospital has not yet seen people apply for one vaccine over another but has not yet offered Johnson & Johnson vaccines. These will be included for the first time this weekend.

The university hospitals are currently vaccinating people in the 1B group, which also includes some people with serious illnesses. People in the 1C group, which includes pregnant women, are currently being pre-registered.

Ohio hospitals learn what vaccine they are receiving from the state every week, said Maureen Nagg, spokeswoman for the St. Vincent Charity Medical Center, a faith-based hospital founded by the Catholic Church. Nagg said St. Vincent was following the direction and guidance of the Catholic Church.

She said St. Vincent will continue to give all three brands of the vaccine, depending on what the state makes available each week. If someone objects to the type of vaccine available, it will be postponed until a time when they can get another brand.

Ms. Koopman said that while he opposes the use of an abortion cell line in the research, development or manufacture of a vaccine, his decision will balance other Catholic principles – such as charity.

“I’m still in a position where I’m with much more vulnerable people and that definitely weighs me down,” he said.

He says he’s not sure this will result in Catholics in northeast Ohio avoiding the Johnson & Johnson vaccine, but stressed that it was their personal choice.

The specialist in infectious diseases, Dr. James Lawler of Nebraska Medicine, a hospital system based in Omaha, said none of the COVID-19 vaccines contained broken fetal cells.

The Johnson & Johnson vaccine was made using cells that are was from tissue taken from an elective abortion in 1985. Pfizer and Moderna also used fetal cell lines in their research, but not in production.

Lawler wrote on the Nebraska Medical website: “Current fetal cell lines are thousands of generations that have been removed from the original fetal tissue.”